Top 10 Insurance Companies in Ontario

Are you looking for affordable insurance companies in Ontario? Do you want to compare different providers to find the best coverage for your needs? Look no further! In this article, we will be discussing the top 10 insurance companies in Ontario. Whether you need auto insurance, home insurance, or life insurance, it’s important to choose a reliable and trustworthy provider that offers competitive rates. With so many options available, it can be overwhelming to narrow down the choices. That’s why we’ve done the research for you and compiled a list of the best insurance companies in Ontario. So sit back, relax, and let us guide you through the process of finding the right insurance provider for you.

Top 10 Insurance Companies in Ontario

1. Desjardins

Desjardins Insurance holds a prominent spot among the top insurance providers Ontario, noted for its comprehensive coverage and competitive premiums that cater specifically to the provincial market. As one of the leading home insurance companies Ontario, Desjardins not only secures homes and properties but also builds lasting relationships with its clients through reliable service and personalized insurance solutions.

Desjardins Insurance

Desjardins’s offerings encompass a wide range of products that include property and casualty insurance, which covers risks such as fire, theft, vandalism, and water damage. Moreover, Desjardins extends its protection services to vehicle owners and those requiring coverage for recreational and lifestyle purposes with auto, recreational vehicle, and even pet insurance options.

  • Individual and group life, health, and dental insurance are notable offerings designed to complement public health provisions effectively.
  • Credit insurance forms a pillar of their financial safety products, reassuring clients under financial liabilities through varying forms of loan and credit insurances.
  • The Ajusto program introduces a revolutionary way to personalize auto insurance premiums based on actual driving behavior, promoting safer driving habits among Ontarians.

Working with a network of seasoned local agents, Desjardins excels in providing tailored advice that encapsulates both individual and business needs, further establishing itself as a responsive and client-focused provider among the insurance companies in Ontario.

Product Type Discount/Savings Offer Special Features
Home Insurance Up to 15% bundle discount Includes Roost home security discounts
Auto Insurance Up to 25% discount for safe driving Accessible digital proof of insurance
Travel Insurance 24/7 Assistance Radar service for weather alerts

With its robust product line, including specialized insurance claims services and innovative programs like Radar and Alert that offer added protection and savings, Desjardins Insurance solidifies its role as a champion of both safety and affordability.

2. Aviva Canada

Aviva Insurance Historical Overview

Among the best insurance companies in Ontario, Aviva Canada stands out with its rich heritage and robust portfolio of insurance products. Established from the roots of CGU Insurance Company of Canada in May 2003, Aviva insurance has evolved into a pillar of trust and reliability in the insurance sector. Serving nearly three million customers, Aviva’s approach to insurance is built on a foundation of extensive experience and customer-focused services.

Aviva Canada is not just one of the leading insurance brokers in Ontario; it’s a comprehensive insurer providing a variety of coverages. The company’s offerings include policies for vehicles (automobiles, ATVs, snowmobiles, boats, motorcycles, RVs), properties (condos, cottages, high-value homes, tenants), and businesses (commercial auto, surety, property, and liability).

Statistics from 2021 reveal Aviva Canada’s significant impact on the market with personal lines net written premiums amounting to approximately $3.667 billion and commercial lines reaching around $2.126 billion. This financial robustness underscores its capacity to support a wide range of claims and insurance needs across various sectors.

Moreover, Aviva Canada’s commitment to societal well-being and environmental sustainability is evident. The company has pledged to achieve net-zero carbon emissions by 2040, backing this with an impressive investment of £7.6 billion in green assets by the end of 2021. Additionally, they contributed $235,000 to charitable organizations supporting DE&I initiatives and disaster relief efforts within the same year.

Customer service at Aviva is also noteworthy. Despite a mixed reception in online reviews, the insurer was honored with the “Best Auto Claims Experience” award, highlighting their proactive and efficient claims processing. This recognition was supported by feedback from nearly 9,000 drivers in Ontario and Alberta, showcasing Aviva’s dedication to excellence in customer interactions.

For homeowners and tenants in British Columbia, Aviva Canada has added an innovative touch to their policies by integrating earthquake coverage at no additional cost, demonstrating their adaptability and focus on customer needs. This is part of Aviva’s broader strategy to expand service availability and options across Canada.

For those considering Aviva insurance, it’s crucial to look beyond surface reviews and understand the deep-seated values and comprehensive offerings that have positioned Aviva as a stalwart among the insurance brokers Ontario trusts and relies on.

3. Belairdirect

Belairdirect Insurance, a prominent name among car insurance companies Ontario, stands out as a direct insurance company, providing straightforward, effective communication and service delivery. With its inception dating back to 1955, this subsidiary of Intact Financial Corporation has grown significantly, encapsulating a rich history of innovation in the direct insurance sector.

Focused primarily on home and auto insurance, Belairdirect offers tailored solutions that resonate well with modern insurance needs. They have pioneered many industry firsts, including being the first North American property and casualty insurer to sell insurance online in 1997. Furthering its commitment to innovation, in 2015, Belairdirect introduced the automerit® program, enhancing savings for safe drivers.

Notably, Belairdirect’s approach to leveraging technology for better service is evident with the implementation of digital proof of insurance in 2019 and the real-time accident detection feature, Crash Assist, introduced in 2021.

Service Features Benefits
Automerit® Program Personalized premiums based on driving habits Encourages and rewards safe driving
Online Services Digital insurance proof, easy claim process Convenience at users’ fingertips, immediate assistance
Bundle Discounts Combining home and car insurance Up to 25% savings on premiums

In addition to these innovations, Belairdirect Insurance provides significant financial benefits through bundle discounts, with savings reaching up to 25% on home insurance when bundled, particularly beneficial for Ontario residents. These offers not only make Belairdirect a competitive player in the market but also reinforce their commitment to providing value to their customers.

Belairdirect Insurance

With approximately 2,000 employees serving around 900,000 customers across Canada, Belairdirect not only matches the population dynamics of cities like Edmonton and Halifax but also reflects a deep penetration in the Canadian insurance landscape. The company’s enduring commitment to providing direct and effective insurance solutions continues to endear it to a wide range of customers, ensuring it remains a top choice among the leading car insurance companies Ontario.

4. Intact Financial Corporation

Among the top auto insurance companies Ontario boasts, Intact Financial Corporation ranks as a leading choice, well-reputed for its extensive broker network and comprehensive service offerings. With a significant presence maintained by over 2,000 insurance brokers Ontario wide, Intact stands as a pillar in the Canadian insurance landscape, offering tailored solutions that meet diverse customer needs.

Intact Insurance not only ensures a robust option for car and home owners but also introduces a multitude of ways to save on insurance policies. These include bundling policies, which can save customers up to $650, and the innovative My Drive™ program, which offers personalized premiums that reflect individual driving habits. Moreover, Intact’s commitment to accessibility and user-friendliness is evident in their 24/7 claims service and a sophisticated mobile app, which allows customers to manage their policies and submit claims anytime, anywhere.

Intact Insurance office

  • 4 million satisfied Intact Insurance customers
  • Coverage options extended even to snowmobile riders in Ontario
  • Digital proof of insurance available through the Intact Insurance mobile app

For those seeking tailor-made advice and a guided insurance selection process, Intact encourages the utilization of expert insurance brokers Ontario-based, ensuring that every client can find the exact coverage they need. This client-centric approach is backed by an array of online tools and resources, including a Whistleblower Hotline to uphold the highest standards of ethics and integrity.

With an impressive track record backed by substantial market share and client satisfaction scores, Intact Financial Corporation not only sustains its rank but continues to set benchmarks in the auto insurance companies Ontario sector and beyond.

5. Economical Insurance

Established in 1871 and revered as one of the most steadfast affordable insurance companies in Ontario, Economical Insurance has evolved significantly over the years, adapting to the needs of over a million Canadians. Providing a gamut of insurance products through a dedicated network of insurance brokers in Ontario, Economical has maintained its reputable stance in the market despite facing challenges in online consumer ratings.

The company champions both traditional offerings and tailored plans encompassing vehicle, home, and business insurance, aligning with the dynamic requirements of its clientele. Economical Insurance notably embraces a broker model to ensure personalized service that respects individual preferences and requirements, thus standing out among affordable insurance companies in Ontario.

One of Economical’s significant attributes is its commitment to community involvement, with investments totalling $1 million annually into various charitable entities. Complementing its corporate responsibility, Economical through subsidiaries like Perth Insurance and Petline Insurance, caters to specialized sectors including high-risk drivers and pet health insurance, showcasing the breadth of its product offerings.

Service Quality Claims Support Innovation Community Impact
92% Satisfaction in Post-Claim Surveys 24/Hour Claims Hotline Digital Insurance Solutions $1M Annual Donations
150 Years in Business AM Best A- (Excellent) Rating Disappearing Deductible Program Supports Over 1 Million Canadians

Moreover, Economical is transitioning from a mutual to a stock company, opening doors for Canadians to partake in its enduring legacy by owning shares. This strategic move not only marks a monumental phase in its history but also enhances its capacity to serve more Canadians comprehensively. With the expansion into being a publicly traded company, Economical secures its position within the panorama of influential and resilient insurance brokers in Ontario, committed to serving the community with integrity and innovation.

6. CAA Insurance Company

Exploring the landscape of insurance companies Ontario, CAA Insurance Company emerges as a significant player. Founded in 1975 and initially renowned for its roadside assistance services, CAA has expanded into the insurance options Ontario sector, offering robust CAA home and auto insurance solutions. This evolution reflects their commitment to adapting and growing alongside the needs of Ontario residents.

CAA Insurance distinguishes itself through a series of innovative offerings. The tailor-made CAA Connect program, for instance, rewards safe driving habits by providing personalized discounts, thereby encouraging a culture of safety and responsibility on the roads. Furthermore, their CAA MyPace® option offers a flexible, usage-based insurance payment plan, ideal for low-mileage drivers looking to reduce their insurance costs.

Feature Description Benefit
CAA Head Start Discount 25% off for drivers under 25 Encourages young drivers to adopt insurance early
Fully Bundled Insurance Up to 12.5% off on bundling auto and home insurance Cost-effective solution for multiple policies
Forgive and Forget® plan Protects your insurance record after first at-fault accident Peace of mind for new drivers
Winter Tire Discount 5% off auto insurance for installing winter tires Rewards preparation for winter driving conditions

CAA’s commitment to customer service is evidenced by their round-the-clock emergency claim support and a user-friendly online Self-Service Portal, which allows policyholders to manage their policies efficiently. With a strong foothold in the community serving over 200,000 families, CAA continues to adapt its offerings, such as introducing CAA Distinct for high-net-worth insurance, securing their place among top insurance companies Ontario.

As CAA Insurance continues to grow and evolve, it remains dedicated to providing trust and value to its policyholders, further cementing its status in the competitive insurance options Ontario marketplace.

7. Allstate

As one of the top rated insurance companies Ontario, Allstate Insurance offers comprehensive Ontario coverage options that cater to a diverse range of needs from home to auto insurance, establishing itself as a pivotal player in the Canadian insurance landscape. Spanning across essential insurance areas, Allstate’s repertoire includes a broad array of products that serve both individual and commercial clients.

Founded in 1953 in Canada and headquartered in Markham, Ontario, Allstate stands as a testament to robust growth and commitment to providing reliable insurance solutions. The company not only offers standard auto and home insurance but also branches out to specialty and commercial insurance, ensuring a wide coverage net for varying needs.

Throughout Ontario, Allstate Insurance is renowned for its tailor-made solutions that span across multiple coverage options. These include traditional vehicle insurance as well as more specialized forms like RV and motorhome insurance, making sure every aspect of client lifestyles is thoroughly protected.

Insurance Type Features Discount Options
Auto Insurance Comprehensive, Collision, Liability New Vehicle, Multi-Vehicle, Anti-Theft
Home Insurance Personal Property, Structure Coverage New Home, Security System, Claim-Free
Life Insurance Term, Whole, Universal Bundle with Auto or Home, Healthy Living

Allstate’s innovative efforts in Ontario demonstrate their market adaptability and customer focus, prominently visible through their Drivewise program that offers up to 30% savings on car insurance for safe drivers. Moreover, Allstate’s responsive claim service and customer-centric initiatives place them high on the list of reliable insurers, reinforcing their standing amongst the top rated insurance companies Ontario.

In conclusion, Allstate’s presence in Ontario not only amplifies their reach but also enriches the Ontario coverage options available to residents, supporting a stable, protected, and financially secure lifestyle.

8. Wawanesa Insurance

As one of the leading home insurance companies in Ontario, Wawanesa Insurance stands out for its comprehensive approach to policies that accommodate a variety of customer needs. Founded in 1896 and with a headquarter in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Wawanesa has developed a reputation as one of the most reliable insurance providers in Ontario, leveraging a network of dedicated brokers to offer personalized service.

Through Wawanesa broker insurance, clients gain access to an array of products including auto, home, and business insurance with enhanced coverage options that cater to individual and corporate clients alike. The company prides itself on supporting policyholders through substantial life changes and claims, providing stability and reassurance in times of need.

Insurance Type Coverage Options Discounts Available
Home Insurance Basic, Broad, Comprehensive Multi-product, Home maintenance
Auto Insurance Collision, Comprehensive, Liability Good driving, Anti-theft, Loyalty
Business Insurance Fire, Theft, Cyber breaches, Third-party liability N/A

With a strategic focus on broker-client relationships, Wawanesa enhances the insurance buying process by ensuring customers have informed advocates on their side. This approach has solidified Wawanesa’s position not just as an insurance provider, but as a community pillar that contributes significantly to local charities and community initiatives.

Choosing Wawanesa not only means selecting a policy but opting into a community of support, making it a preferential choice for those who value thorough, personable, and reliable insurance providers in Ontario.

9. Manulife

As a leading figure among insurance providers Ontario, Manulife stands out not only for its extensive array of services but also for its stellar reputation in financial services Ontario. With over 130 years of rich history, Manulife has bagged the title of not only being the largest but also one of the most reliable insurance firms in Canada, offering diversified Manulife coverage options to cater to individual and enterprise needs alike.

Manulife’s expansive portfolio includes not just conventional insurance products such as health, life, and travel insurance, but also specialized plans like disability, critical illness, and mortgage protection insurance. This variety ensures every demographic and age group can find a tailored solution fitting their specific circumstances and stages in life.

Enhancing customer experience, Manulife prioritizes digital accessibility, allowing clients effortless access to policy statements and transactions through secure online platforms. This digital advancement aligns seamlessly with Manulife’s mission to simplify insurance processes for its clients, further supplemented by a plethora of educational resources and detailed videos explaining various insurance products and benefits.

  • Membership perks from affiliations with groups like Costco ensure that clients always receive more value than what they invest.
  • Personalized advice from experienced insurance advisors helps tailor solutions meticulously to meet individual protection needs.
  • Through innovative tools such as their mobile app, Manulife extends the convenience of managing group benefits plan, submitting claims, and reviewing coverage balances on the go, ensuring support is just a click away.

Indeed, these combined traits reinforce why Manulife not only stands at the forefront among insurance providers Ontario but also marks its excellence globally as the 28th largest fund manager based on institutional assets managed worldwide.

10. Sun Life

Embarking on the journey of insurance decision making in Ontario requires a comprehensive exploration of the various offerings available. Sun Life, a prominent player in the sector, provides robust solutions tailored to diverse needs. Serving individuals up to the age of 85, Sun Lifeinsurance options present extensive coverages, including not only life insurance but also meticulous health insurance plans.

When Ontarians compare insurance companies, they do so with an acute awareness of the prerequisites; cost efficiency, breadth of coverage, and ease of claims. Sun Life stands out for affordability with premiums commencing as low as $12 per month for qualifying demographics, and highlights the notion that annual life insurance payments generally carry more economic benefit than monthly installments. Shifting to health coverage, Sun Life’s personal health insurance plans distinguish themselves through varying levels of reimbursement and coverages that address preventive, dental, orthodontic, and vision care, as well as emergency medical expenses during travel. The Basic, Standard, and Enhanced plans each offer gradations of protection, ensuring a match for every budget and set of requirements.

In times of uncertainty, it’s crucial to have protective measures that extend beyond workplace-provided plans, fostering continuous safety nets for those we cherish. Advisors at Sun Life provide personalized consultations, guiding clients through the nuanced process of selecting apt life and health insurance policies. As Sun Life insurance options evolve to reflect changing consumer needs, the brand reinforces its stature in insurance decision making in Ontario, illustrating the crucial role of informed choice in the maintenance of long-term wellbeing.


In conclusion, when it comes to finding affordable insurance companies in Ontario, it’s crucial to take the time to compare different options. The insurance market is competitive, and by shopping around, individuals can ensure that they’re getting the best coverage at the most affordable price. Fortunately, there are plenty of resources available online that make comparing insurance companies quick and easy.

When comparing insurance companies in Ontario, it’s important to look at not only the premiums but also the coverage and customer service they offer. While it’s tempting to go for the cheapest option, it’s essential to ensure that the insurance company has a good reputation and is financially stable. Reading reviews and checking for complaints can help in making an informed decision.

Additionally, it’s worth considering bundling insurance policies to save even more money potentially. Many insurance companies offer discounts to policyholders who purchase multiple policies from them. Therefore, individuals should explore options to bundle their auto, home, and other insurance policies under one provider.
Overall, finding affordable insurance companies in Ontario can be challenging. However, with careful consideration and by comparing different options, individuals can find the right coverage at a price that won’t break the bank. By investing the time and effort upfront, individuals can have peace of mind knowing that they are adequately protected and getting the best value for their money.


1. What are some of the best insurance companies in Ontario?

Notable insurance companies in Ontario include Desjardins Insurance, Aviva Canada, Belairdirect Insurance, Intact Financial Corporation, Economical Insurance, CAA Insurance Company, Allstate, and Wawanesa Insurance. Providers like Manulife and Sun Life also play a significant role in Ontario’s insurance industry.

2. How do I compare insurance companies in Ontario to find the best fit?

You can compare insurance companies in Ontario by looking at factors such as customer reviews, product offerings, customer service, pricing, and the ease of filing claims. Tools and resources such as KBD Insurance can help you curate a list of top-rated insurance companies to compare their offerings.

3. Why is Desjardins Insurance considered a top insurance provider in Ontario?

Desjardins Insurance is regarded as a leading insurance provider in Ontario due to its high customer satisfaction ratings, a broad spectrum of insurance products, and the financial benefits of bundling policies.

4. Does Aviva Canada offer both home and car insurance?

Yes, Aviva Canada offers both home and car insurance, and it is known for its long-standing history and reputation for trustworthiness. However, it is advisable to look beyond reviews and carefully assess their service offerings.

5. What sets Belairdirect Insurance apart from other insurance companies?

Belairdirect Insurance stands out as a direct insurance company offering efficient communication and streamlined arrangements for home and auto insurance policies. It is a subsidiary of Intact Financial Corporation and is recognized for its straightforward approach to providing insurance.

6. Which insurance companies utilize the broker model in Ontario?

Companies such as Aviva Canada, Economical Insurance, and Wawanesa Insurance utilize a broker model to distribute their insurance products. This model allows for personalized guidance and detailed attention to individual client needs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *